Community October 27, 2021

Great Places to Pre-Order Your Thanksgiving Pies

If baking pies isn’t your favorite thing on your Thanksgiving to-do list, these wonderful local bakeries have got you covered. Just make sure to order ahead so you can get your favorites before they sell out!

Bigleaf Maple Bakery in Poulsbo

Not only can you order Thanksgiving desserts from this new Poulsbo bakery, but you can also pre-order a quiche to take one more thing off of your to-do list. Offerings for Thanksgiving will include a variety of sweet treats, including gingersnap pumpkin pie and 3-inch butter tartlets. Orders must be placed by November 14th. You can pick up your order on Wednesday, Nov. 24th from 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM. To learn more about this new bakery, check out our recent interview with them.

Borrowed Kitchen Bakery in Kingston

This year, Borrowed Kitchen Bakery will be offering apple and pumpkin pies, which are the mainstays of most Thanksgiving tables. You can also pre-order Thanksgiving dinner for 2 and other delicious items. Ordering starts after Monday, November 1st, and the deadline to place your order is Saturday, November 20th. They also offer a delicious citrus orange cranberry sauce, a perfect condiment for your turkey meal. Order can be picked up on Wednesday, November 24th from 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM. 

McGavin’s Bakery in Bremerton

This Bremerton staple not only has sweets for your Thanksgiving meal, but it is also offering pre-orders for dinner rolls, and cheddar rolls as well. Their menu for pre-orders includes pies such as pumpkin, apple, and pecan, as well as their signature pumpkin cheesecake. Orders must be placed no later than 3:00 PM on Saturday, November 20th. 

Monica’s Waterfront Bakery & Cafe in Silverdale

This Silverdale favorite offers pre-order pies year-round in a variety of flavors. Apple, pumpkin, berry, cherry, and other seasonal flavors are available. Give them a call to order. For Thanksgiving orders, plan to call about two weeks in advance, but non-peak times require only 48-hours notice. They are also happy to work with custom orders and can make other flavors upon request.

Sluys Poulsbo Bakery in Poulsbo

This Poulsbo spot might be known best for their donuts, but they offer a wide variety of other baked goods as well. Pies for Thanksgiving can be pre-ordered until Monday, November 22nd. Flavors available are apple, blackberry, cherry, strawberry, strawberry-rhubarb, raspberry, pecan, pumpkin, and dutch apple. Each pie weighs in at close to 3 lbs. They will have lots of pies on hand for walk-in service as well. However, if you have a specific flavor in mind, it’s best to place your order in advance.

Sweet Life Cakery in Kingston

This cute little shop is a few blocks from the Kingston ferry terminal and offers a wide variety of sweet treats and cute decor. Their Thanksgiving pre-order menu includes classics like apple and pumpkin as well as local favorites like salted caramel apple and whiskey pecan. They offer gluten-free, vegan pie crust for an extra $8 as well as regular crust. Their vegan pie options include mixed berry, sour cherry, and classic apple. You can order whole 9-inch pies and/or cute 4-inch “pielets”.  For the chocolate lovers in your family, add their signature Sweet Blisses to your order. All Thanksgiving orders must be placed by Wednesday, November 17th by 5:00 PM. Thanksgiving pickup is available on Tuesday, November 23rd, or Wednesday, November 24th.